Skip to content
Logout Icon Logout
2010 Oral History Interview

Mr. David Scott

Lawyer
Interview Details
Year: 2010
Pages: 321
Date: Aug 2010
Status: Open

David William Scott, Q.C., born January 27, 1936, represents the fourth generation of a distinguished Ottawa legal family, with roots tracing back to his great-great-grandfather Sir Richard Scott who helped select Ottawa as Canada’s capital. Educated at Ashbury College and Loyola College, Scott began his career combining criminal defense with part-time Crown prosecution before forming the litigation-focused firm Scott & Aylen, which grew to nearly 50 lawyers before merging with Borden Elliott to create a national firm.

Scott’s career was marked by extensive involvement in royal commissions and public inquiries, beginning with the 1976 Marin RCMP Inquiry and continuing through major investigations including the McDonald Inquiry (which created CSIS), the Stevens Inquiry, the APEC Inquiry, and notably the Gomery Inquiry into the sponsorship scandal where he represented Jean Chrétien. His practice encompassed significant litigation including his first Supreme Court appearance in Batary v. Saskatchewan (1965), patent litigation, defamation cases, and high-profile matters involving public figures like Joey Smallwood and Pierre Trudeau. Beyond his legal practice, Scott served as a Law Society of Upper Canada Bencher from 1991, held leadership positions in The Advocates’ Society and Canadian Bar Association, and made history as the first Canadian President of the American College of Trial Lawyers, traveling across 42 states in that role.

This description was written by AI and may contain some inaccuracies.

References

The following are a selection of topics discussed in this oral history.

Courts
  • County Courts
  • Court of Queen's Bench
  • Division Court
  • Federal Court
  • Federal Court of Appeal
  • Ontario Court of Appeal
  • Provincial Courts
  • Superior Court of Ontario
  • Superior Court of Quebec
  • Supreme Court of Canada
Educational Institutions
  • Laval University
  • Osgoode Hall Law School
  • Queen's Law School
  • University of Calgary
  • University of Ottawa Law School
  • University of Saskatchewan
  • University of Toronto Faculty of Law
  • Western Law School
Government Bodies
  • Competition Bureau
  • CSIS
  • Department of Justice
  • Health Canada
  • House of Commons
  • National Defence
  • Parliament
  • Patent Office
  • Prime Minister's Office
  • Privy Council Office
  • RCMP
Historical Events
  • APEC summit demonstrations
  • Bre-X Scandal
  • Canadian Airborne Regiment disbandment
  • Conrad Black peerage controversy
  • Court Merger Reform
  • Establishment of CSIS
  • Great Depression
  • Real estate bubble burst 1991/1992
  • Somalia deployment
  • Sponsorship scandal
  • Tainted blood scandal
  • World War II
Jurisdictions
  • Alberta
  • Australia
  • British Columbia
  • Calgary
  • Canada
  • England
  • Germany
  • Indonesia
  • Montreal
  • Newfoundland
  • Ontario
  • Ottawa
  • Quebec
  • Saskatchewan
  • Scotland
  • Toronto
  • United States
  • Vancouver
Law Firms
  • Aylen, Scott & Aylen
  • Blakes
  • Borden & Elliot
  • Borden Ladner Gervais
  • Ewart, Scott, Kelly & Howard
  • Fraser Beatty
  • Gowlings
  • Lang Michener
  • McCarthy Tétrault
  • McMillan Binch
  • Oslers
  • Scott & Aylen
  • Smart & Biggar
  • Torys
Legal Cases
  • AG v. Information Commissioner of Canada
  • APEC Inquiry
  • Batary v. Saskatchewan
  • Black v. Chrétien
  • Gomery Inquiry
  • John Turner v. CBC
  • Krever Inquiry
  • Netupsky v. Craig
  • Proctor & Gamble v. Kimberley Clark
  • R. v. Felderhof
  • R. v. Furesz
  • Smallwood v. Sparling
  • Sniderman Radio Services v. Sylbert Sales Ltd.
  • Somalia Inquiry
  • Stevens Inquiry
Occupations
  • Lawyer
Oral History Tags
  • Non-Toronto
People Mentioned
  • Arthur Maloney
  • Brian Mulroney
  • Charlie Dubin
  • Conrad Black
  • Cuthbert Scott
  • David William Scott
  • Earl Cherniak
  • Eddie Greenspan
  • Horace Krever
  • Ian Scott
  • Jean Chrétien
  • Joey Smallwood
  • John Aylen
  • John Robinette
  • John Sopinka
  • Justice Gomery
  • Louise Arbour
  • Pierre Trudeau
  • René Marin
  • Richard Scott
  • Roy McMurtry
  • Sinclair Stevens
  • Susan Elliott
Professional Organizations
  • American College of Trial Lawyers
  • Canadian Bar Association
  • Criminal Lawyers Association
  • Law Society of Upper Canada
  • Patent and Trademark Institute of Canada
  • RCMP Complaints Commission
  • Scott Commission
  • The Advocates' Society
  • Thomas More Lawyers Guild
Time Periods
  • 1930s
  • 1940s
  • 1950s
  • 1960s
  • 1970s
  • 1980s
  • 1990s
  • 2000s
Topics
  • Access to Information
  • Administrative Law
  • Charter Rights
  • Civil Litigation
  • Competition Law
  • Conflict of Interest
  • Constitutional Law
  • Criminal Law
  • Criminal Procedure
  • Defamation Law
  • Evidence rules
  • Intellectual Property Law
  • Judicial Independence
  • Parliamentary Privilege
  • Patent Law
  • Professional Liability
  • Professional Misconduct
  • Public Inquiries
  • Reasonable apprehension of bias
  • Solicitor-Client Privilege

Some of these references were generated by AI and may contain inaccuracies.

For information about this oral history, please contact the Osgoode Society.