Skip to content
ELCA Logo Logout
1995 Oral History Interview

The Right Hon. Antonio Lamer

Judge
Interview Details
Year: 1995
Pages: 295
Interviewer: Christine Kates
Status: Open

This oral history interview with Chief Justice Antonio Lamer covers his life from childhood in 1930s Montreal through his distinguished judicial career. Born in 1933 to a French-Canadian father and Irish-Canadian mother, Lamer attended strict Catholic boarding schools and served in the military before studying law at Université de Montréal. He built a successful criminal law practice, handling high-profile cases including FLQ trials during the October Crisis and the landmark Robert Miron murder case that led to Criminal Code amendments on transferred intent.

Appointed to the Quebec Superior Court in 1969, Lamer dramatically reduced case backlogs before serving as Vice-Chair and Chair of the Law Reform Commission of Canada (1972-1979). After a brief stint on the Quebec Court of Appeal, he joined the Supreme Court of Canada in 1980, becoming Chief Justice in 1990. His tenure coincided with the Charter of Rights and Freedoms era, where he authored influential decisions on fundamental justice, criminal procedure, and constitutional interpretation. Key cases discussed include Big M Drug Mart (freedom of religion), Operation Dismantle (justiciability), Oakes (section 1 analysis), and various criminal law precedents involving mens rea, evidence exclusion, and Charter protections. The interview provides insights into Supreme Court dynamics, judicial administration, and the evolution of Canadian constitutional law during a transformative period.

This description was written by AI and may contain some inaccuracies.

References

The following are a selection of topics discussed in this oral history.

Courts
  • Alberta Court of Appeal
  • British Columbia Court of Appeal
  • Exchequer Court
  • Federal Court
  • Federal Court of Appeal
  • Montreal Municipal Court
  • Ontario Court of Appeal
  • Privy Council
  • Quebec Court of Appeal
  • Quebec Superior Court
  • Saskatchewan Court of Appeal
  • Supreme Court of Canada
  • U.S. Supreme Court
Educational Institutions
  • College de St. Laurent
  • McGill University
  • Osgoode
  • Oxford
  • Université de Montréal
  • University of Toronto
Government Bodies
  • Attorney General of Canada
  • Attorney General of Quebec
  • Canadian Judicial Council
  • Department of Justice
  • House of Commons
  • Law Reform Commission of Canada
  • Montreal Police Department
  • National Judicial Institute
  • Order of Canada
  • Parliament
  • Privy Council
  • Quebec Provincial Police
  • RCMP
  • Senate
Historical Events
  • Charter of Rights and Freedoms introduction 1982
  • Constitution Act 1982
  • Cross kidnapping
  • Death Penalty Abolition
  • Expo 67
  • First World War
  • FLQ Crisis
  • Great Depression
  • Laporte murder
  • October Crisis
  • Quiet Revolution Quebec
  • Second World War
  • War Measures Act
Jurisdictions
  • Alberta
  • British Columbia
  • Canada
  • England and Wales
  • France
  • Manitoba
  • Montreal
  • New Brunswick
  • Ontario
  • Quebec
  • Saskatchewan
  • United States
Law Firms
  • Cutler and Associates
  • Cutler, Lamer, Bellemare & Associates
  • Lamer & Lamer
  • Walsh and Walsh
Legal Cases
  • B.C. Motor Vehicle Act
  • Big M Drug Mart
  • Edwards Books
  • GST Reference
  • Milgaard Reference
  • Morgentaler
  • Operation Dismantle
  • R. v. Askov
  • R. v. Chaulk
  • R. v. Collins
  • R. v. Creighton
  • R. v. Dubois
  • R. v. Finlay
  • R. v. Genereux
  • R. v. Gosset
  • R. v. Logan
  • R. v. Mills
  • R. v. Naglik
  • R. v. Oakes
  • R. v. Vaillancourt
  • Rothman v. The Queen
  • Sault Ste. Marie
  • Smith v. R.
  • Stinchcombe
Occupations
  • Judge
Oral History Tags
  • Supreme Court of Canada
People Mentioned
  • Allan Gold
  • Antonio Lamer
  • Arthur Martin
  • Beverley McLachlin
  • Bora Laskin
  • Brian Dickson
  • Claude Wagner
  • Fred Kaufman
  • Jacques Bellemare
  • Jean Beetz
  • Jean Chrétien
  • John Turner
  • Justice Chouinard
  • Justice Cory
  • Justice Estey
  • Justice Gonthier
  • Justice Iacobucci
  • Justice L'Heureux-Dube
  • Justice LaForest
  • Justice Major
  • Justice McIntyre
  • Justice Sopinka
  • Justice Wilson
  • Louise Arbour
  • Morris Fish
  • Philip Cutler
  • Pierre Trudeau
  • René Lévesque
  • Robert Miron
Professional Organizations
  • Association of Defence Counsel
  • Canadian Bar Association
  • Canadian Human Rights Foundation
  • Canadian Institute for the Administration of Justice
  • Canadian Medical Association
  • Liberal Party
  • Montreal Bar
  • Montreal Reform Club
  • Quebec Bar
  • Young Liberals
Time Periods
  • 1930s
  • 1940s
  • 1950s
  • 1960s
  • 1970s
  • 1980s
  • 1990s
Topics
  • abortion law
  • Bail
  • Charter of Rights and Freedoms
  • Constitutional Law
  • constructive murder
  • court procedure
  • Criminal Law
  • cruel and unusual punishment
  • Death Penalty
  • delay in criminal proceedings
  • Disclosure Law
  • Evidence Law
  • Freedom of Religion
  • fundamental justice
  • Judicial Independence
  • Jury Trials
  • Law Reform
  • Legal Ethics
  • Manslaughter
  • mens rea
  • Minimum Sentences
  • Murder
  • Oakes test
  • Preliminary Inquiries
  • Search and Seizure
  • section 1 analysis
  • section 24(2) exclusion of evidence
  • Section 7
  • Sentencing Law
  • transferred intent

Some of these references were generated by AI and may contain inaccuracies.

For information about this oral history, please contact the Osgoode Society.